Buddy Punch vs Time Doctor: Full Comparison
Buddy Punch is a time clock for hourly and field teams, with GPS and photo capture. Time Doctor tracks remote teams with screenshots and activity scores.
Free to start. No credit card needed.
Our quick verdict on both tools
Pick Buddy Punch if your team clocks in from a job site, a store, or a shift, and you want GPS, photo verification, and scheduling in one place. Pick Time Doctor if your team works at a computer, often remote or outsourced, and you need proof of what they did during the hours logged, plus payroll built in.
Start tracking freeWhat this comparison covers
Buddy Punch and Time Doctor are both time tracking tools, compared here side by side so you can see how they differ.
Worth a look too: TimeTracker takes a different path, tying tracked hours to project budgets and client invoicing instead of a physical time clock or screen monitoring.
Compare the two products at a glance
Both tools solve time tracking. Here is what each one includes, side by side.
Buddy Punch
An easy time clock with a lot of ways to prove who punched: GPS on every punch, plus geofencing, PIN and kiosk punching and a webcam photo from the Pro tier up.
- Best for
- Small and mid-size hourly or field workforces that want an easy time clock with GPS and scheduling.
- Pricing
- No free plan, 14-day trial only. Billed annually: Starter $4.99, Pro $6.99, Advanced $12.99 per user a month, each plus a $19 monthly base fee. Extras are sold per user on top.
- Punch in/out from web, mobile, or kiosk
- GPS coordinates on every punch
- Geofencing, PIN and kiosk punching (Pro)
- Webcam photo on punch (Pro)
- Scheduling, included from Pro
- PTO accrual and approvals
Time Doctor
Pairs strict activity monitoring (screenshots, keystroke activity, idle alerts) with built-in payroll and client-facing reports.
- Best for
- Distributed and outsourced teams, agencies, and BPOs that need proof-of-work evidence tied to billing.
- Pricing
- No free plan, 14-day trial only. Billed annually: Basic $6.67, Standard $11.67, Premium $16.70 per user a month. Month to month it is $8, $14 and $20. Eleven paid add-ons sit on top, from $2 a user a month up to $200 a month each for payroll sync, HRIS sync, SSO and provisioning.
- Idle detection and distraction alerts
- Random screenshots with optional blur
- Activity level scoring
- Website and app usage tracking
- Payroll reports and attendance data (Standard+)
- 60+ integrations (Standard plan+)
- Client login for shared reports
See how they stack up
Pricing, best fit, and top strengths for both tools, side by side.
Pricing checked 2026-07-31. Confirm current pricing on each vendor's site.
Which one fits your team
Choose Buddy Punch when…
Your staff clock in from a job site, store, or other physical location.
GPS tracking with a live map view shows where a punch happened, which matters for field and retail teams more than screen activity does.See how
You want to stop buddy punching without adding hardware.
Photo capture on clock-in confirms who actually punched in, a check Time Doctor's desktop-focused monitoring does not offer.See how
You need a hard boundary around where staff are allowed to clock in.
Geofencing with a configurable radius blocks a punch outside the job site, which fits field crews better than a desktop app.See how
You want scheduling and time tracking in one tool, not two.
Drag-and-drop scheduling is native to Buddy Punch, so shifts and punches live in the same system instead of a separate app.See how
You do not want to monitor screens, keystrokes, or app usage.
Buddy Punch tracks clock-in and clock-out, not what happens on a screen, which suits teams who find that kind of monitoring too invasive.See how
You want GPS and location features without paying for the top tier first.
Location features are available from Buddy Punch's lower tiers, unlike tools that gate GPS behind a premium plan.See how
Choose Time Doctor when…
You manage remote or outsourced staff and need proof that work actually happened.
Random screenshots and an activity level score give you evidence beyond a clock-in time, which matters when staff are offshore or on contract.See how
You want payroll paid out from the same tool that tracks the hours.
Time Doctor builds payroll payments in, so hours-to-payout is one workflow instead of a punch clock plus a separate payroll app.See how
You bill agency clients and want them to see hours worked directly.
Client login gives clients their own view of logged hours, which is unusual among time clock tools built for field teams.See how
Your team works at a computer and you need to catch idle time or distractions.
Idle detection and distraction alerts flag time that looks logged but was not actually worked, something a physical time clock cannot see.See how
You run a BPO or outsourcing shop and need auditable activity history.
Website and app usage tracking builds a record an outsourcing client can review, not just a total hours count from a punch clock.See how
You want integrations plus payroll without stitching together a separate payout tool.
Time Doctor's Standard plan and up bundle 60 plus integrations and built-in payroll into one subscription.See how
Popular features
Employee time tracking your team will actually use
One click starts a timer, or people type hours in by hand. Every entry ties to a client, project, and task, so the record stays clean.
Explore Time Tracking→Bill for every hour you earn
Mark each entry billable or non-billable while you work. Approved hours roll straight into reports you can bill from.
Explore Billing→See where the time really goes
Break hours down by client, project, and team member. Find the work that pays off and the projects that run over.
Explore Reports & Dashboards→Use cases this solves
Frequently asked questions
- Is Buddy Punch cheaper than Time Doctor?
- Usually, yes. Buddy Punch starts around $4.49 a user a month plus a base fee. Time Doctor has no free plan and starts at $8 a user a month with no base fee. Total cost depends on team size, so check the billing page to see how billing setups differ across tools.
- Does Buddy Punch take screenshots like Time Doctor?
- No. Buddy Punch tracks clock-in and clock-out with GPS and an optional photo, but it does not take screen screenshots. Time Doctor takes random screenshots with an optional blur, and scores activity level. For a lighter approach to logging hours, see non-billable time tracking.
- Which tool is better for managing outsourced or offshore staff?
- Time Doctor is built for this. Screenshots, activity scores, and app and website usage tracking give a manager evidence beyond a clock-in time, which matters when staff work offshore or on contract. See how utilization tracking works for teams that need this kind of visibility.
- Which tool is better for field or on-site staff?
- Buddy Punch fits field and on-site teams better. GPS tracking, geofencing, and photo capture on clock-in confirm where and who punched in, which matters more for a job site than a screen activity score. See billable hours tracking for how hours get tracked in the field.
- Does either tool pay staff directly?
- Time Doctor builds payroll payments into the product, so hours convert straight into a payout. Buddy Punch does not run payroll itself, though its timesheets export for an external payroll tool. Read more about billable hours tracking to see how tracked hours get used downstream.
- How do scheduling features compare?
- Buddy Punch includes drag-and-drop scheduling as a native part of the product, so shifts and punches sit side by side. Time Doctor focuses on tracking and monitoring hours already worked and does not build in shift scheduling the same way. See time tracking for the tracking basics both tools share.
- Which tool has more integrations?
- Time Doctor offers 60 plus integrations, but only from its Standard plan and up. Buddy Punch's integration list is smaller and leans toward payroll and HR tools rather than a broad app marketplace. Either way, both cover the core reporting most teams need without extra tools.
- Can clients see logged hours directly in either tool?
- Time Doctor offers a client login so agency clients can view logged hours themselves, which is unusual in this category. Buddy Punch does not build this in the same way, since it is built more around internal shift management. See client reporting for how shared reporting typically works.
- Is Time Doctor's monitoring too much for a small in-house or field team?
- For a field team already covered by GPS and geofencing, Time Doctor's screenshots and activity scoring can feel like the wrong kind of tracking. Buddy Punch's location-based approach usually fits better there. See time tracking for what a simple clock-in setup looks like.
- Are there other options besides Buddy Punch and Time Doctor?
- Yes. If neither tool fits, a broader list of options is worth checking, including TimeTracker, which is built around project budgets and client invoicing rather than a physical time clock or activity monitoring. Our alternatives directory covers more ground than this one page.
Ready to pick the right time tracker?
Buddy Punch and Time Doctor solve different problems. Weigh location tracking against activity monitoring, then check a few more options before you commit.
Compare alternatives